Quran Talk Blog, Community

Quran Talk BlogThree Reasons Behind Omitted Details in QuranThe Quran leaves some details unstated for three reasons: they are insignificant, as with the number of the sleepers of the cave; they require exploring the text more deeply; or the reader is expected to know them already. Salat, Zakat, Hajj, and Ramadan illustrate the third reason, with the Quran addressing only disputed points because it is complete and fully detailed.November 17, 2023

Quran Talk BlogRefuting The Typical Arguments Against Quran AloneCommon traditionalist arguments for upholding Hadith beside the Quran are answered one by one with Quranic verses and early sources. Covered claims include obeying the messenger, Hikma as Sunnah, the need for Hadith to judge, explain the Quran, or perform the contact prayer, a shared source with the Quran, the reliability of isnad, and the majority being right. Accounts of the early caliphs suppressing Hadith also appear.November 16, 2023

Quran Talk BlogFallibility of the Companions (Sahahba)The traditionalist claim that every companion of the prophet is trustworthy faces challenges from the Quran: the gang that slandered a woman in 24:11, the unknown hypocrites of Sura 9, and companions who deserted the Quran. The article also examines how the broad definition of a companion shortens hadith chains, early caliphs restricting hadith, and hadith as conjecture, concluding that the Quran is the only testimony to uphold.November 5, 2023

Quran Talk BlogThe Sweat of Muhammad’s LightDaqaiqul Akhbar, a book popular among Muslims especially in Indonesia, teaches that creation sprang from the sweat of Muhammad's light, beginning with Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman, and Ali. Dr. Rashad Khalifa read this passage in a November 1987 sermon as an example of idolizing the prophet. The article translates the excerpt, calls it blasphemy that rivals God, and compares it to the Hindu caste origin myth of Brahma.November 5, 2023

Quran Talk BlogThe Names of MuhammadLists of 99, 202, and even thousands of names attributed to Muhammad are examined as setting him up as a rival to God. The article distinguishes a name from an attribute, arguing that because God is Absolute, none can share His names, and it points to names such as Merciful, Almighty, and Truth that the Quran uses for God alone.November 4, 2023

Quran Talk BlogAbraham on the Day of Resurrection According to HadithSahih Bukhari 3350 describes Abraham meeting his disbelieving father Azar on the Day of Resurrection and pleading with God not to be disgraced. The article sets this hadith against the Quran, citing Abraham's prayer in 26:87, his disowning of his father in 9:114, God's promise in 39:61 that the righteous will have no grief, and 23:101 on the end of all relations that day.November 3, 2023

Quran Talk BlogNuN CountsThe spelling of the initial N at the start of Sura 68 as Noon Wow Noon, which Dr. Khalifa held brings the sura's count of N to 133, 19×7. The article answers critics who say manuscripts use a single letter, citing Shady Hekmat Nasser's catalog of variant readings and Ibn Khalawayh's treatise. It also notes 19-based counts tied to the last initial and the naming of Jonah.October 29, 2023

Quran Talk BlogMulti-Meaning VersesThe multiple-meaning verses of the Quran, as described in 3:7, which itself can be read two ways. Examples include the ablution's wiping or washing of the feet, the death of Jesus, and marking the hands of thieves, along with how Sunnis, Shias, and Mutazilites approached such verses. The article argues these verses test whether believers fall into sectarian quarreling, and urges patience with differing interpretations.October 26, 2023

Quran Talk BlogGaming IsnadsHadith transmitters and compilers manipulated the isnad, the chain of narrators, to make it look shorter and so more reliable. The article examines the differing criteria of Bukhari and Muslim, relay men in lecture halls, misleading phrases like haddathana, companions narrating events they never witnessed, centenarian and child transmitters, uncertain birth and death dates, and the ijaza system of transmission permission.October 21, 2023

Quran Talk BlogWhen Sahihs DisagreeSunni Hadith scholars disagree over which narrations count as Sahih, from Bukhari and Muslim's differing criteria and trusted transmitters to Ibn Hajar, Ibn al-Jawzi, and Abu Hanifa rejecting accepted reports such as the satanic verses. Examples include conflicting ratings on sunnah.com and Al-Shafi'i's near absence from the collections. The article concludes that Hadith Sciences is no real science.October 21, 2023

Quran Talk BlogMiserable is what he decidedThe Arabic word qaddara in Sura 74:18 to 20, describing the disbeliever who calls the Quran human made, means a calculated or measured decision rather than a simple choice. Its five other Quranic occurrences, all about God's precise design, support this reading. The article ties the word to the mathematical miracle of the Quran and notes its gematrical value and verse positions as multiples of 19.October 13, 2023

Quran Talk BlogMuhammad’s SinsMuhammad's mistakes and sins as the Quran records them answer the claim that he was sinless. The examples include his being astray and worshiping idols before messengership, excusing men from battle, taking captives, frowning at the blind man, fearing people over marrying Zeid's former wife, and prohibiting what God made lawful. Calling him infallible is presented as idolizing a human messenger.October 13, 2023

Quran Talk BlogEvolution of Hadith Reliance in Sunni IslamThe four Sunni schools of jurisprudence, from Hanafi through Maliki and Shafi'i to Hanbali, each lean more on Hadith than the one before. The article argues that Abu Hanifa ruled almost entirely from the Quran, that works crediting him with Hadith were later fabrications, and that the canonization of Bukhari and Muslim drew all four schools away from the Quran.October 12, 2023

Quran Talk BlogIbn Sayyad: The Dajjal That Never WasSahih Hadith narrations about Ibn Sayyad, a boy the prophet reportedly suspected of being the Dajjal, a figure absent from the Quran. The article sets these beside Hadiths predicting an imminent end of the world and reports of Ibn Sayyad growing into a believer who contemplated suicide over the rumor. It argues traditionalists must then doubt either the prophet's judgment or the Hadith sciences.September 20, 2023

Quran Talk BlogWhat do you need to see to renounce Hadith?Four historical claims, set by a Discord challenger who asked what proof would make him renounce Hadith, are answered here: Bukhari died an outcast and his collection was canonized centuries later; Hadith were mass fabricated under the Umayyads; Umar and Abu Bakr suppressed Hadith and urged the Quran alone; and Sunni Islam arose long after the prophet. Quranic verses on following the Quran alone close the case.September 19, 2023

Quran Talk BlogWho Started Today’s “Quran Alone, God Alone” Movement?Dr. Rashad Khalifa is presented as the first to unite total rejection of Hadith with an uncompromising call to worship God alone, founding today's Quran alone movement. His Quran based arguments against Hadith and idol worship are reviewed, followed by a comparison with earlier critics such as Syed Ahmad Khan, Muhammad Abduh, Ghulam Ahmed Pervez, and Muhammad Tawfiq Sidqi, who rejected Hadith partly or not at all.September 13, 2023

Quran Talk BlogExcerpts & Thoughts from Hadith Literature by Muhammad Zubayr SiddiqiExcerpts from Muhammad Zubayr Siddiqi's study of hadith literature, with commentary, show early caliphs such as Abu Bakr and Umar discouraging the narration and writing of hadith in favor of the Book of God. The notes question how narrations attributed to Companions like Ibn Abbas multiplied in later generations, and examine the major compilations, the reliability of isnads, and fabrication.September 11, 2023

Quran Talk BlogAhruf & QuranThe hadith claim that the Quran was revealed in seven ahruf is examined against the Quran and the historical record. Each scholarly theory, from synonyms and dialects to Ibn Mujahid's seven recitations, multiple meanings, and kinds of verses, is weighed and rejected. The article concludes the concept is a fabrication, links the root of ahruf to distortion, and holds that Code 19 identifies the one Quran.September 7, 2023

Quran Talk BlogSura 27 Word CountThe word count of Sura 27 from the opening Bismillah to the Bismillah in verse 30, given in Appendix 1 as 342, or 19 x 18, against claims of 349. Counting conventions decide the total: whether to include either Bismillah, as in the footnote for 40:34, and whether a negation particle with its verb counts as one word. Classical Arabic negation particles are explained along the way.September 5, 2023

Quran Talk BlogOldest Quran ManuscriptsThe Quran's transmission is traced through a catalog of its oldest known manuscripts, from the Birmingham leaves and the Sana'a palimpsest to the codices attributed to Uthman in Cairo, Istanbul, Tashkent and Topkapi. Each entry gives radiocarbon or scholarly dating, script, location, and how much of the text survives, noting that the Birmingham manuscript conforms to the standard text and may date to the prophet's lifetime.September 4, 2023

Quran Talk BlogOldest Hadith ManuscriptsNo Hadith manuscript survives from the first century after the Hijra; the oldest is a single Muwatta page from about 176 AH. The article traces the earliest surviving copies of Gharib al-Hadith, Ma'mar's Jami, the Sahifa of Hammam, the Risala, Bukhari, and Muslim, and shows that the Berlin and Damascus Sahifa copies are not originals. It also notes textual variations among recensions.September 2, 2023

Quran Talk BlogHistory of BasmalahThe Basmalah, the opening statement found at the start of 113 of the 114 suras, predates the Quran, as Solomon's letter to the Queen of Sheba shows. Each of its four words is traced to earlier messengers such as Noah, Abraham, Moses and Mary. Also covered are the oldest known pre-Islamic Basmalah inscription, from Southern Arabia, and a parallel in Exodus whose Hebrew phrase has 19 letters.September 1, 2023

Quran Talk BlogWhat is the Most Gracious?The Quran's question in 25:60, What is the Most Gracious?, seems to clash with verses showing the Arabs knew this name of God, used by Abraham, Aaron, and Mary. Drawing on Ahmad al-Jallad's study of South Arabian inscriptions, the article argues the Hijazi Arabs linked ar-Rahman with Christians and asked in defiance, not ignorance. An appendix counts its 57 occurrences, 19 times 3.September 1, 2023

Quran Talk BlogGender & SocietyPharaoh's killing of the sons of Israel serves as a model for a present push to suppress masculinity in men and masculinize women. The article cites falling testosterone from obesity and plastics, career pressure on women, rising depression among young liberal women, and gender transition among teen girls. It closes with Quran verses on God creating male and female and blames parents who follow pop culture.August 25, 2023

Quran Talk BlogThree Forms of Idol WorshipVerse 3:64 names three things a submitter must avoid: worshiping other than God, associating anything with Him, and taking others as lords beside Him. The article explains each from the Quran, from loving God most and making Him the first priority to subtle forms of association. It ends by rejecting intercession by messengers, scholars, and religious leaders as setting up lords between people and God.August 24, 2023

Quran Talk BlogTraits of True Worshipers of God AloneWorshiping God alone means serving Him as one's only master, and the Quran's verses show what that entails. The Arabic words for worship and voluntary obedience lead into loving God the most, giving Him priority over family and wealth, answering the Friday prayer, gratitude, doing good to please God, and recognizing that only God can harm or benefit, as the calf worship of the Children of Israel illustrates.August 22, 2023

Quran Talk BlogWho Explains the Quran?God Himself explains the Quran, not the prophet, according to a study of every Quranic root used for explaining: faṣṣala, sarraf, afta, bayyana and tafsir. Verses such as 75:19 and 25:33 show God and the scripture doing the explaining, while the messenger's sole duty is clear delivery of the message. The messenger may judge or clarify only by the Quran itself.August 18, 2023

Quran Talk BlogShahada to ShahadatanThe Quranic testimony of faith, that there is no god beside God, is contrasted with the dual Shahadatan, whose added statement about Muhammad appears in the Quran only from the hypocrites in 63:1. Early coins, the Dome of the Rock, and rock inscriptions trace the Shahadatan to the reign of the Umayyad caliph Abd al-Malik, about 65 years after the prophet's death.August 15, 2023

Quran Talk BlogSeven Ajwa Dates & PoisonSahih Hadith claiming that seven ajwa dates each morning protect against poison and magic face the test of reality and a proposed controlled study. The article contrasts them with narrations that the prophet suffered from poison eaten at Khaibar and felt his aorta being cut, the very punishment the Quran in 69:44 to 46 describes for one who fabricates revelation, and concludes that such Hadith insult the prophet.August 13, 2023

Quran Talk BlogTrust and SocietyTrust as the fabric holding society together, illustrated through the chain of trust behind an online purchase and the damage a single package theft does to it. California's Proposition 47, lax enforcement of theft laws, and looting in San Francisco show how corruption spreads when unpunished. Drawing on the Quran's account of Midyan and verses on oaths, it urges submitters to uphold moral integrity.August 7, 2023

Quran Talk BlogBasmalah Word CountThe Basmalah, the Quran's opening verse, and its ties to the number 19: its 114 occurrences, its 19 letters, and the counts of Allah, Al-Rahman, Al-Rahim, and ism as multiples of 19. Early manuscripts and the traditional 786 gematrical shorthand show the letter count went undisputed before the mathematical miracle's discovery. Professor Cesar Majul's findings on divine names with gematrical values divisible by 19 are also covered.July 16, 2023

Quran Talk BlogThe Prophet’s Miracle or Miracles?The Quran names the Quran itself as the prophet's only miracle, and this piece sets that claim against Hadith reports of many wonders. Verses 10:20, 29:50 to 51, and 17:59 are contrasted with Bukhari and Muslim narrations of a split moon, water flowing from his fingers, a crying palm stump, walking trees, and multiplied food. The author concludes the Hadith are fabrications.July 10, 2023

Quran Talk BlogThe ChallengeEarth's rare fitness for life and science, from liquid water and plate tectonics to the magnetic field, the moon, and perfect solar eclipses, is set against the Drake Equation and paired with Quran verses. The article then argues that the Quran's challenge to produce a sura like it reaches beyond language, to prophecy, scientific facts, the test of time, and the Code 19 structure of the Quranic initials.July 6, 2023

Quran Talk Blog4 Witnesses & HadithThe Quran's requirement of four witnesses in cases of adultery (4:15, 24:4, 24:13) is applied to Hadith, arguing that a statement attributed to the messenger demands at least that standard. Because each link in a chain of narrators would need four witnesses, seven links would require 16,384, a number no Hadith approaches. Ibn al-Salah's admission that at most one Hadith qualifies as mutawatir supports the case.July 4, 2023

Quran Talk BlogAmin and SalatThe custom of saying Amin after reciting al Fatihah in the Salat, examined through an excerpt from The Study Quran citing a hadith and Sunni practice. The piece notes there is no certainty about what the word means or how it entered the Salat, distinguishes it from the word for safe, and objects that traditionalists add it while leaving out the Bismillah.June 20, 2023

Quran Talk BlogSura 96 and Code 19Sura 96, The Embryo, the first revelation, and its Code 19 features: 19 words and 76 letters in the first five verses, 19 verses, and 285 letters overall. The article defends counting ma-lam in 96:5 as one compound word, citing Quranic compounds, the limits of old manuscripts, Ahmad Deedat, classical Arabic dictionaries, and the Risalah of al-Shafi'i.June 19, 2023

Quran Talk BlogA Covenant From The ProphetsVerse 3:81 records a covenant God took from the prophets, not from the people of the scripture, as some claim. Grammatical parallels in 3:187, 2:83 and 5:12, the contrasting wording of 7:169, and the context of 3:79 and 3:80 support the plain reading. Verse 33:7, which names Muhammad, Noah, Abraham, Moses, and Jesus, confirms the covenant was taken from the prophets.June 17, 2023

Quran Talk BlogKnow Your EnemySatan as the Quran portrays him, man's most ardent enemy who attacks from all sides and duped Adam, is set against the Hadith's picture of a bumbling, comical devil. The article argues that, like Hannibal feigning weakness at Cannae, Satan spread these narrations so people underestimate him, abandon God's warnings in the Quran, and follow inherited tradition.June 16, 2023

Quran Talk BlogWives of the Prophet like MothersVerse 33:6 serves as an example of a multiple meaning verse, read here as describing the closeness of the prophet's wives to the believers rather than actual motherhood. Drawing on 3:7, 58:2, 33:4 and 33:40, the article argues that motherhood in the Quran requires giving birth, so calling the prophet's wives mothers of the believers is mistaken, just as Muhammad was not the father of any man.June 12, 2023

Quran Talk Blog2:54 Kill Yourselves?Verse 2:54 is often read as God commanding the Children of Israel to kill themselves or the calf worshipers among them. Testing that reading against the Quran's own criteria, including no contradictions, no compulsion in religion, no legal punishment for idol worship, and the Samarian's banishment rather than death, the article argues that nafs here means ego, so the command was to kill their egos.June 5, 2023

Quran Talk BlogThe Prophet’s Farewell Sermon: What He Left BehindConflicting hadith accounts of the prophet's Farewell Sermon disagree on what he left to keep believers from going astray: the book of God alone, or with his family, or his Sunnah. The article rules out the family and Sunnah versions using the First Fitna and the Quran's own use of sunnah. It concludes he left the Quran alone, citing deathbed narrations and 25:30.June 5, 2023

Quran Talk BlogWord Count of 9:128-129Word counts in the Quran show that including 9:128-129 pushes words such as messenger, Merciful, Lord and throne one past a multiple of 19, while omitting the two verses restores the multiples. Say and they say each occur 332 times unless the say in 9:129 is counted. God's warning in 3:78 against fabricated scripture is noted alongside 9:127 as the true last verse of Sura 9.June 3, 2023

Quran Talk BlogAbu Lahab and HadithThe traditionalist argument that Hadith is needed to know who Abu Lahab was gets a two part rebuttal. The single Hadith story about him adds nothing beyond Sura 111, whose figurative bearer of firewood marks his wife as an instigator of the opposition. Knowing such identities, like which Pharaoh opposed Moses, has no bearing on salvation, since God left nothing out of the Quran.June 1, 2023

Quran Talk BlogWas the Prophet Ever Bewitched?Hadith in Sahih al-Bukhari claiming the prophet was bewitched and imagined doing things he had not done are weighed against the Quran. Only disbelievers in the Quran call him bewitched or crazy, while 68:2 affirms he was never crazy and 5:67 promises God's protection until he delivered the message. The piece faults those who uphold baseless Hadith over the Quran alone.June 1, 2023

Quran Talk BlogMutawātir, Hadith, Quran, & SalatMutawātir, the idea of a report passed down by so many people that fabrication is impossible, fails as a defense of Hadith, since anything truly mutawātir needs no chain of narrators. The Quran, guarded by God and by Code 19, is the only genuinely mutawātir text. The Salat itself is mutawātir, inherited since Abraham, and the Quran settles disputes over its details.May 31, 2023

Quran Talk BlogThe Religion of the QuraishThe Quraish of the prophet's time believed in God, performed Hajj and the contact prayers, and denied their idol worship rather than bowing to statues. Verses from the Quran, sixth century monotheistic inscriptions discussed by Professor Gabriel Said Reynolds, and narrations from Bukhari and Muslim support the case. Most people today likewise fail to recognize their own idol worship.May 31, 2023

Quran Talk BlogHell is ForeverHell is eternal, according to the Quran, against the Hadith teaching that some of its inhabitants will eventually leave. The article traces the Arabic terms khaladan, abad, and muqim through many verses, showing that the people of Hell never exit. It also answers the common appeal to 11:107, arguing that the heavens and earth of the Hereafter endure forever by God's will.May 24, 2023

Quran Talk BlogThose Who Do Not Menstruate (65:4)Quran 65:4 and the claim that its phrase those who do not menstruate permits child marriage. The article reads the verse as a divorce interim rule, cites 4:6 on the maturity required for marriage, and argues the phrase means adult women not menstruating because they are pregnant. It also addresses the word lam and rejects past practice as a justification for sin.May 24, 2023

Languages

With each verse

Quran Talk Blog