Quran Talk Blog, Community

Quran Talk BlogThe Golden Calf of IslamThe story of Moses, Aaron, and the golden calf in Sura 20 is read as a pattern repeated in every generation. The Arabic word athar, meaning both footsteps and tradition, links the Samarian's dust from the messenger's footsteps to Bukhari and the Hadith collectors, whose books Muslims uphold beside the Quran. Those who, like Aaron, see the idolatry but stay silent for fear of dividing the umma are urged to speak out.August 11, 2022

Quran Talk BlogThe Motte-And-Bailey Fallacy and HadithThe motte and bailey fallacy, as Hadith upholders use it, defends Hadith by pointing to modest narrations while avoiding the objectionable ones that contradict the Quran. A sample of narrations from Bukhari and Muslim illustrates the point, and the article notes that no Hadith details how to perform the Salat. Verses 6:112 to 6:115 present the Quran as complete, fully detailed, and the only source of religious law.August 10, 2022

Quran Talk BlogMaking Up Days of FastingMaking up missed days of the Ramadan fast, drawing on verses 2:184 and 2:185. Those who are ill or traveling substitute an equal number of other days, while those who fast with great difficulty may feed one poor person for each day they break the fast. The article reads the Arabic word yuṭīqūnahu as meaning the person still attempts to fast, since fasting is best.August 9, 2022

Quran Talk BlogSecure Communication and EmojisSecure messaging, from Telegram's emoji check to wax seals and encryption, serves as an analogy for how God preserves the Quran. The fourteen sets of Quranic initials over 29 suras, interlocked with the number 19, authenticate the text and expose any distortion, as Sura 74 describes. The code is presented as the miracle for the age of cryptography, foretold in the Gospel of Truth.August 8, 2022

Quran Talk BlogDo you know what…is?The Quran's pattern of asking whether the reader knows what a term is, then defining it, as with Sijjeen, Al Taareq, the Shocker and the Devastator. The article argues that God never explains the contact prayer, obligatory charity, fasting or pilgrimage because these rituals were already known through the religion of Abraham, which Muhammad was instructed to follow.August 6, 2022

Quran Talk BlogJanus Words In QuranJanus words, terms that carry both a meaning and its opposite, appear in English and in Arabic, where they are called al-ad`daad. The article looks at such words in the Quran and explains that context decides which meaning applies: a positive context calls for the positive sense, a negative context for the negative one.August 6, 2022

Quran Talk BlogSatanic AbrogationThe traditional doctrine that some Quran verses abrogate others is rejected, with the argument that ayah in its singular form in 2:106 and 16:101 means a sign, miracle, or the whole Quran, never a single verse. The article reads the Verse of the Sword in its wartime context, presents the Quran as complete and free of contradiction, and contrasts it with conflicting Hadith such as the seven ahruf.August 4, 2022

Quran Talk BlogNafl SalatThe traditional practice of Salat Al-Nafl, extra non-obligatory prayers, is weighed against the Quran's five set times for the Contact Prayers. Tracing the word nafl through its four Quranic occurrences, especially 17:79, and through Hadith, the article argues that nafl means bonus righteous work such as night meditation, not additional Salat, and that the prescribed prayers should be neither increased nor decreased.July 28, 2022

Quran Talk BlogThe Lost Fabricated VersesHadith claims that verses on stoning and adult breastfeeding were part of the original Quran and were lost when a sheep ate them. The article sets the stoning claim against the Quran's penalty of one hundred lashes, halved for freed slave women, and examines the Arabic of the alleged verse from Sunan Ibn Majah. It concludes that the Quran is complete, fully detailed, and the only source of religious law.July 26, 2022

Quran Talk BlogWho Claimed Masses From The Sky? (Part II)The demand in 17:92 that masses fall from the sky as claimed is read as addressed to Rashad Khalifa, the messenger of the covenant, rather than the prophet Muhammad. The smoke prophecy of Sura 44, the meaning of well educated but crazy, the unnamed community of Sura 26, Khalifa's renderings of 52:44 and 2:101, and his March 1990 newsletter claims support the argument.July 21, 2022

Quran Talk BlogMarking the HandsThe punishment for theft in verse 5:38 and two common misreadings of it. The word usually rendered sever is shown by its use in Sura 12 and its contrast with 5:33 to mean cut or mark, with mathematical signs based on 19 offered in support. The dual form for hands is read as referring to the male and female thief, not both hands of one person.July 19, 2022

Quran Talk BlogA Comprehensive Guide: The Distinction Between Prophet (Nabi) and Messenger (Rasool)The Quranic distinction between prophet (nabi) and messenger (rasool), argued from verse patterns, word roots, and the covenant in 3:81. Prophets are given scripture, wisdom, and prophethood, while messengers disseminate God's message, so every prophet is a messenger but not every messenger a prophet. Because Muhammad was the final prophet, the article concludes that the Quran is the final scripture.July 15, 2022

Quran Talk BlogQuran One Time RootsChallenges the claim that the Quran's language explains itself through internal usage alone, without lexicons or dictionaries. Many Quranic roots carry several meanings, such as the root of Islam, which covers submission, peace, and greeting, and 415 of roughly 1790 roots occur only once. Counts of rarely used roots and the verses they affect show the limits of that method.July 8, 2022

Quran Talk BlogHadith of God vs. the Hadith of MenIdol worship that people deny they practice, exposed by the Quran's question of who creates, frames an argument that the Quran is God's Hadith and cannot be matched. Hadith attributed to the prophet are treated as a human attempt to produce another Quran, with examples on adultery punishment, dietary prohibitions, and ablution where they contradict it. Upholding any source of religious law beside the Quran is called idol worship.July 7, 2022

Quran Talk BlogSmellThe sense of smell as a neglected gift from God, from its role in taste, mood, and present awareness to its place in the lives of the messengers. Jacob sensing Joseph's shirt, Jesus telling what people ate, and Solomon hearing the ant are read alongside research on ant pheromones. The shared Arabic root of spirit and smell is linked to how Muhammad recalled the Quran and to the reminder.June 23, 2022

Quran Talk BlogJasadan Upon Solomon’s Throne 38:34The meaning of jasadan in Quran 38:34, the word for what God placed on Solomon's throne as a test, is weighed against its other Quranic uses for the calf statue and an effigy. Three readings are tested against the verse's structure of trial and submission: a statue signifying vast wealth, as in Dr. Khalifa's translation, a corpse, and a corps of jinns, humans, and birds, which the author favors.June 21, 2022

Quran Talk BlogSubtractionRighteousness, the article argues, often comes from removing what people have added to the religion beyond the limits God sets in the Quran. It traces this error from the Children of Israel to Muslim additions in ablution, food prohibitions, the Shahadah, prayer times, and Hajj to Medina. The most important subtraction is setting up idols beside God, including following sources other than the Quran.June 15, 2022

Quran Talk BlogDid Hud Receive Proof for His Messengership?Hud's messengership and the claim, based on 11:53, that he brought no sign, so a messenger need not provide one. The article answers that the denial came from disbelievers, then cites 11:59, 14:9, and 9:70, with the Arabic words ayat and bayyinat, to show that Hud brought clear proofs to Ad. It rests on the three requirements of a messenger set out in Appendix 2.June 12, 2022

Quran Talk BlogQuran and HikmahThe Quranic term hikmah, wisdom, and whether it is separate from the scripture, as traditional Muslims claim to justify Hadith. The article argues the wisdom is embedded in the Quran and open only to the sincere, reading the Arabic wa in 33:34 as marking a subset. It also draws on Sura 66 and the prophet's wives to argue against Hadith as a source of religious law.June 12, 2022

Quran Talk BlogWho Claimed Masses From The SkySingular and plural address in the Quran's Arabic raise the question of which messenger claimed in 17:92 that masses would fall from the sky, since Muhammad never did. The article links that claim and the smoke prophecy of Sura 44 to Rashad Khalifa as the messenger of the covenant, citing 3:81, the root of Rashad occurring 19 times, the believing Egyptian of Sura 40, and his final Submitters Perspective words.June 10, 2022

Quran Talk BlogThe Pursuit of TruthTruth and falsehood are weighed by depth: truth holds up under scrutiny while falsehood falls apart. Starting from the axioms that God is the Truth and the Quran is His word, the article argues against upholding Hadith beside the Quran, offers a method of studying the Quran by removing contradictions, reads verse 3:7 on allegorical verses, and urges seeking refuge in God from one's own hidden bias.May 26, 2022

Quran Talk BlogMiserable Is What He DecidedSura 74, The Hidden Secret, describes a man who examined the 19-based mathematical miracle of the Quran and declared it human made. The Arabic word qaddara in verses 18 to 20 implies a decision based on calculation or measurement, unlike other Quranic words for deciding. Its gematrical value of 304, its verse numbers totaling 57, and its position as the 57th word are all multiples of 19.May 23, 2022

Quran Talk BlogThe Power of OneThe righteousness of a few believers, the article argues, is what keeps whole communities from destruction. It draws on Lot and his family, Satan's respite, the parable of the weeds, the believing man among Pharaoh's people, and the two reverent men of the Children of Israel. It then extends the strong anthropic principle to a moral version, holding that God created the universe for those who deserve redemption.May 19, 2022

Quran Talk Blog33:21 and HadithQuran 33:21, which calls the messenger of God a good example, is often cited to justify Hadith. Read in context, the verse refers to the prophet's conduct during the Battle of the Parties, and following lies attributed to him differs from following his actual example. The same word for example is applied to Abraham, and the Quran contains every example and is the only source of religious law.May 13, 2022

Quran Talk BlogLay of the LandTwo societies in the Quran, the people of Lot and the community that persecuted the people of the cave, serve as models of the hedonistic and the religious authoritarian extremes. Both deny freedom of speech and religion, against the Quran's rule of no compulsion in religion and its call for a balanced community. The article argues that the United States today is drifting toward the people of Lot.May 13, 2022

Quran Talk BlogWhere Atheism Leads SocietyRemoving God from society leads not to atheism but to polytheism, the article argues, since the creed there is no god except God leaves only lesser gods once God is taken out. It answers militant atheists such as Hitchens and Dawkins, holds that everyone worships something, and cites the Quran on the ego as god, Satan's aims, and the chaos that multiple lawgivers bring.May 11, 2022

Quran Talk BlogAbraham’s ScriptureWhether the Quran shows that Abraham received a written scripture from God. The article surveys Quranic words for scripture beyond kitab, traces the root of suhuf as written manuscripts through 80:11 to 80:16, and points to 53:36 to 53:37 and 87:18 to 87:19, which name the suhuf of Abraham and Moses.May 10, 2022

Quran Talk BlogWhen Does The Night Start?Night begins at sunset, the article argues, settling when believers may break the Ramadan fast. It examines how the Quran speaks of sunset and the darkness of 17:78, holds that night and day are binary states with no time between them, and distinguishes the whole night from ʻisha. Verses 50:39 and 20:130 name sunrise and sunset as the two ends of the day.May 7, 2022

Quran Talk BlogBoth Ends of The DayThe phrase both ends of the day in 11:114 and 20:130 is examined, testing dawn and sunset, after sunrise, and noon as readings and showing how each creates a contradiction. A closer look at the Arabic of 20:130, reading wa as an oath, identifies the ends as before sunrise and before sunset. These match the Dawn and Afternoon contact prayers, consistent with the Quran having no contradictions.May 6, 2022

Quran Talk BlogThe Prophet’s Locations Mentioned in the QuranResponding to the claim that the prophet Muhammad and the Quran originated in Petra rather than Mecca, the article lists places the Quran names, including Yathrib, Badr, Hunayn, Mecca, Becca, Safa and Marwah, and Arafaat, with their distances from Mecca and Petra. It shows the Kaaba, the Sacred Masjid, and the Shrine are one place tied to Hajj and the Quraish. It then applies Occam's razor to favor Mecca.May 4, 2022

Quran Talk BlogTranslating 38:44Job in verse 38:44, a verse many translators render as taking a bundle of grass or even beating his wife. The article rejects the tafsir story of Job's oath, reads ḍigh'than as confusion from its uses in 12:44 and 21:5, and examines the hand idioms and the root of ḍ'rib. It concludes that Dr. Rashad Khalifa alone translates the verse correctly, as a command to travel the land and preach.May 3, 2022

Quran Talk BlogRequited For Only OneGod's mercy in judging deeds, drawn from the Quran: a righteous work earns the reward for ten while a sin is requited for only one. Money spent in the cause of God is multiplied manifold, God overlooks many sins, and those who repent find their sins transformed into credits. The article closes by answering disbelievers who argue that God is not just.April 29, 2022

Quran Talk BlogSatan and FalsehoodSatan's aim of making people believe falsehood, with idol worship as its greatest form: believing anything besides God can harm or benefit, or accepting sources that contradict God. The article traces how Satan deceives individuals and whole societies, naming modern political and cultural claims as examples, faults Hadith and Sunnah as religious falsehood, and presents reading the Quran and seeking refuge in God as protection.April 28, 2022

Quran Talk BlogThe Fourth Dietary ProhibitionThe fourth dietary prohibition, whether it covers any food dedicated to other than God or only animals slaughtered in the name of other than God, is argued from 6:145, the Arabic word uhilla, the footnotes, and Appendix 16. Mentioning God's name before eating, the practices named in 5:3 and 5:103, intoxicants, and Rashad Khalifa's recorded explanations also figure in the case.April 21, 2022

Quran Talk BlogThe Kernel of RighteousnessSincerity is presented as the kernel of righteousness, the foundation that lets a person understand and apply the Quran. Starting from the responsibility of free choice humans accepted in 33:72, the article explains why innate monotheism, a sense of right and wrong, experts, messengers, and scripture are not enough alone. It closes with the contact prayer as the means God gave to purify and guard that sincerity.April 21, 2022

Quran Talk BlogLabbaykHajj and Umrah, decreed once in a lifetime for those who can afford it, commemorate Abraham's submission to God and must be observed during the four Sacred Months, a timing most Muslims have distorted. The steps are traced in order: Ihraam, circling the Ka`bah while proclaiming Labbayk, Safa and Marwah, the day at Arafat, Muzdalifah, sacrifice and the stoning of Satan at Mina, and the farewell circumvolution.April 19, 2022

Quran Talk BlogExtravagant Zakat?Answers the argument that Zakat cannot be 2.5% because 17:26 warns against being excessive when giving the due alms. Zakat at 2.5% is presented as the minimum obligation, paid on the day income is received, while giving more is encouraged within limits, citing verses on charity and extravagance and a Quran study where Rashad Khalifa explains the same point.April 16, 2022

Quran Talk BlogDisproving “The Wrapped One Code”A Pakistani claimant to messengership proposes a formula he calls The Wrapped One Code, said to yield multiples of 19 from any unique Quranic word. Testing seven rare words, the author finds only one hit, in line with the 2 in 19 chance expected. He argues that adding more methods only raises the odds and weakens any claim of a miracle.April 15, 2022

Quran Talk BlogPreservation of the Quran Past and FutureGod's promise to preserve the Quran, read as a system that detects and corrects distortion rather than a bar on tampering. Memorization, the written mus'haf and Classical Arabic grammar are reviewed, then Code 19 is presented as the fourth mechanism that settles variant recitations, spellings, verse counts and the added verses 9:128 to 129 in favor of Hafs. Possible future proofs are also considered.April 14, 2022

Quran Talk BlogMuhammad: The Importance of LiteracyHadith claims that the prophet Muhammad was illiterate yet founded the Suffa school in Madina to teach others to read and write. The article argues this would make him guilty of saying what he does not do, which the Quran in 61:2 and 61:3 calls most abominable in the sight of God, and that the claim of his illiteracy contradicts the Quran.April 13, 2022

Quran Talk BlogQuran, Hadith, and AbrogationHadith reports claiming the Quran lost or gained material are examined, including the satanic verses, a longer Sura 33, forgotten suras, the stoning and suckling verses, the Basmalah dispute, and the seven ahruf. The article argues that the word ayah in 2:106 and 16:101 means a miracle, not a verse, and that abrogation contradicts the Quran's claim to be complete and free of contradiction.March 26, 2022

Quran Talk BlogThe Parent’s ResponsibilityRaising righteous children amid a corrupting society begins with the parents' own righteousness, since guidance comes only from God. Drawing on the Quran, the article urges parents never to condone sin, to enjoin the contact prayer as Noah, Abraham, Ismail and Luqman did, and to have children marry believers. It closes on trust in God through the stories of Abraham, the orphans' righteous father, and Jacob's quiet patience.March 24, 2022

Quran Talk BlogAbraham and the FatehahThe Contact Prayers and other rites of submission go back to Abraham, which raises the question of how the Fatehah could match the language Abraham spoke. The article compares Arabic with Hebrew, Aramaic and Syriac, sets the Fatehah beside a Hebrew prayer drawn from the Old Testament, and argues that Classical Arabic, preserved among the descendants of Ismail, kept closest to the original Semitic tongue.March 21, 2022

Quran Talk BlogGender BabelVerse 2:102 and the two angels of Babel, Haroot and Maroot, are read as a warning about distorting the meaning of words until distinctions disappear, with the breaking up of marriages understood as erasing the distinction between man and woman. The article applies this to same-sex marriage, shifting gender roles, transgender identity, and schools and law, citing 4:32 and 4:34 on men as bread earners.March 17, 2022

Quran Talk BlogNabi and Rasool (con’t)The Quranic distinction between prophet (nabi), who is given scripture, and messenger (rasool), who explains and confirms it, shows prophets to be a subset of messengers. Drawing on Suras 19 and 6, the article traces prophethood through the Children of Israel, names the Arab messengers Hud, Saleh, and Shu'aib, and argues that Muhammad was the final prophet but not the final messenger, pointing to the believing Egyptian and Rashad.March 1, 2022

Quran Talk BlogNabi and RasoolThe Quranic distinction between nabi, a prophet who is given scripture directly from God, and rasool, a messenger who delivers and confirms an existing message, drawing on 3:81 and the Arabic roots of both words. The article also traces nabi to the Babylonian scribal deity Nabu and cites verses to argue that Muhammad could read and write and wrote the original Quran himself.February 28, 2022

Quran Talk BlogPower and ResponsilbityPower from God, whether knowledge, wealth, or freedom of choice, carries matching responsibility, starting from the human acceptance of freedom of choice in 33:72. Solomon's wealth, his care for the ants, and the knowledge taught at Babel show how provisions can draw a person toward God or away. Those who have the Quran's message are held more responsible than those who have not received it.February 26, 2022

Quran Talk BlogImitation Versus RealityPeople's preference for imitation over reality, traced from look-alike contests, processed food, filtered selfies, pornography, and sensationalized news such as the Kyle Rittenhouse coverage, to religion. The deification of Jesus and the replacement of the Quran with Hadith, including the false Shahadah, show the same pattern. Quranic verses call the Hereafter the real life and warn that habitual falsehood blinds people to the truth.February 18, 2022

Languages

With each verse

Quran Talk Blog