Severing Hands

Contradictions

Anti-Hadith Hadith Quran the only thing the prophet left The only book left by the prophet Fabricated Hadith Warning Quran is Sufficient Follow Laws only in Quran Accept Only Hadith That Align with Quran Companions Refrain from Hadith Companions Forbidden to Ask Prophet About Matters Do not write anything other than Quran Best Hadith is Quran The only preserved divine revelation was Quran Beware of Hadith The character of the prophet is Quran Allah curses propagators of Hadith Do Not Trust Hadith Alone Hadith innovators can't be helped in Hereafter Obedience is required only in what is maruf Prophet's only miracle was Quran Obedience Conditional (Date Farming)What to do if disagree regarding Quran Are the dead punished for the weeping of their relatives?The Prophet's Will Beware of the Sahaba Show your isnad Lying About Muhammad La Ilaha Illa Allah

Don't Elevate Prophet No Superiority Among Prophets Do not make distinctions among prophets of God Don't exaggerate praise of prophet Prophet's judgment was falliable Prophet can't intercede Don't Call the Prophet Sayyid Don't worship the prophet Prophet's only miracle was Quran Prophet doesn't know his future Prophet Not Better Than Yunus (Jonah)Prophet's Knowledge About Quran was Limited Muhammad just human Joseph more patient Moses more patient Abraham best of creation Muhammad Did Not Explain Quran Graves of the Prophet Don't Praise the Companions Companion Innovators

Hadith insults the prophet Prophet considers suicide Prophet Bewitched Prophet's Shyness Prophet Cripples a Boy Moses's Scrotal Hernia David Recited Quran Jesus Declares Himself a Liar Prophet's Aorta Solomon's wives Covering Corpse with Saliva Abraham was a liar Muhammad had intercourse while fasting Prophet was two-faced Prophet burned an ant colony Prophet forgot suras of Quran Homo Man fornicates with the mother of the prophet's son Prophet had lice Prophet Had Evil Seminal Fluid Muhammad ate meat sacrificed to idols Muhammad's Child Nemesis (Ibn Sayyad)

Wives of the Prophet Fondling (Sex During Menses)Semen Stains Sexual Relations Married a PoW in a single day Sauda's figure 'Aishah Breastfed Grown Men 'Aishah performed ghusl for her nephews Marries a Slave Prophet Fulfilling Need 66:1 Backstory Tongue Sucking During Fasting Aisha Mocking Khadijah

Views on Women Majority in Hell are women Most deficient in intelligence and religion Wives to prostrate to husbands Sex Slaves Wife's responsibility Need Husband Permission to Fast Female Genital Mutliation Women Naturally Crooked Temporary Marriage Temporary Marriage During Pilgrimage Virgin Consent Women are bad omens Tricking virgin an orphan slave girl to marry is allowed Intercourse with Spouse is a Charity Adult male suckling Prohibited to Travel Alone Forbid returning home at night from a journey Nullify Salat

Pedo Hadith Pedo Homo Tounge Hasan Slave Children Why not marry a slave child?Tricking an orphan slave girl to marriage is permissible Aisha's Age Child Definition

Violence Assassinations Killing Captives Adhan Attack Sex Captives Threat to burn houses of those who did not show up for Salat Harming Women and Children Torture and Mutliation Baby girl going to hell Child Born Out of Wedlock Worse than Parents Kill Apostate Evicting and killing Jews and Christians Severing of Hands Honor Killing of Pregnant Woman Kill homosexuals Beating as a punishment (Drinking)Execute Drunkard on 4th Time Pro-Slavery Reward for financing war Umar kills his son by flogging Flogging Wife and Slave Kill Future Quran Reciters Stoning Adulterer Kill man who marries father's wife Monkey Adultery Kill dogs Kill lizards Kill snakes Kill Vermin

Contradictions First Revelation Last Verse Revealed Don't Follow Commands that aren't Maruf Last Sura Marrying the aunt of one's wife Kill, Don't Kill Age of 60 Only Salat are the Prescribed Salat Breathing while drinking Did the Prophet Preach Shouting in the Market?Drinking While Standing Those in Hell Follow/Don't Follow Ruler Leave a Will Retaliation for Poisoning Lying one leg ontop of the other Laylat al Qadr Uncertainty Punishment for Intoxication Abraham's Intercession Do not talk about personal sex lives God is shy?Anti-Hijab Cupping Urinate Standing/Squatting Cauterization Poetry at Masjid Marrying in Ihram Solomon Wives 3 Sacred Masjids Killing Frogs No Assassinations Location of Farewell Sermon Farewell Sermon Did the Prophet Know the Future (Unseen)?Ka'ba Rebuilt Punishment for having a dog What interrupts Salat Abraham's Dream Adult suckling 2 Sister Marriage Paternity Determination Intercession by Muslims Temporary Marriage Punishment for adultery Dajjal Cyclops Dajjal Eye Eating Animals with Fangs Deceased Tormented Days in Mecca Tattooing, removing hair from the face Guaranteed Paradise Fortune telling Fasting Worst lie Prophet's only miracle was Quran End of the World 100 Years Severing Hands Years in Mecca & Prophet's Life Span Age of death Abu Bakr and Umar 600 wings Hajj: Quran or Hadith?Umra and Hajj of the Prophet Woman Travel 25x or 27x Sanctified Lying Sacred Months Mutilation Don't Turn Houses into Graves Jesus Return Intercourse during breastfeeding All prophets tended sheep Don't Make Unlawful for yourself 66:1 Renting Land for Produce Punishment for bestiality Wudu Before Intercourse if Junub Praying After Asr

Dietary Prohibitions Donkey Meat Beast of Prey with Fangs Odd Number of Dates Garlic and Onions Prohibition

Random Prohibitions Pictures Dog Prohibition Tattoos, False Hair, Facial Hair Gold Rings Wedding Invite Saffron Prohibited to fast on Fridays Statues and Graves Cleaning Privates Combing Hair Every Day Don't eat with left hand Forbidden Mourning Bells are for Satan Lick fingers after eating Drinking from certain cups Drink while Standing Laughing at passing wind Pants below ankles Dying the hair black Reciting Quran While Bowing or Prostrating Marrying Wife's Aunt Throwing Stones Wearing one shoe Don't touch penis with right hand Wash Hands in Morning Perfume at the masjid Items must be separated before being sold A slave that runs away is a Kufr Silk Forbidden Soiled Urine Deserves Eternal Torture

Salat Confusion 50 Salat Salat Fateah and Bismillah One Rakah Salat Spitting During Salat Combining Salats Salat Times Asr Salat Time Praying After Asr Muhammad Legislate Prayer Time Double Salat Salat Names Isha Salat During Menses Salat al-Wusta Shoe ablution Eyes are the leather strap of the anus Adhan Fake Salat Salat is lost Hand Raising Salat Interlacing Fingers Bowing Qibla Nullifying Salat Salat & Zakat (Ridda Wars)Rak'a

Wudu Confusion False Wudu The Perfect Wudu Wudu for every Salat Sleeping Breaks Wudu (Yes/No)Wudu Before Intercourse if Junub Cooked Food and Wudu Sprinkle Privates for Wudu Wudu after eating camel meat What Breaks Ablution Wudu & Quran Recitation Rinsing the Nose Ghusl for Friday Prayer Wudu Once or Thrice Siwak and Wudu

Ramadan Confusion White thread of light Cupping breaks fast Kissing and Intercourse while Fasting Expiation For Breaking Fast Fasting on behalf of others

Companion Confusion Raising Hadith Salat Prayer Asr Salat Time

Prophet Miracles Muhammad's Only Miracle was Quran Moon split Finger Flowing Stream Crying Stem Talking Trees Talks to animals Lots of dates Greeted by a stone Escorting trees Stopped the sun Prophet Knew the Future Rain Food for the masses Well

Idolizing the Prophet The Prophet's Spittle Prophet beard hair Prophet's Intercession Prophet Didn't Need Food or Drink Sweat of the prophet The most entitled The Prophet's Names Prophet's Handsomeness Talking from the grave?Prophet Bodies Don't Decay Prophets Are Alive in their Grave Eyes behind his head The Prophet's Hands Friday Salat is For Sending Blessings to the Prophet Adhan for Sending Salat to Prophet Prostrating to Muhammad Seeking refuge in Muhammad

Mimic The Prophet Start with the right How to eat How to eat dates Circumcision at Puberty Pluck Armpit Hairs Never ate at a table Never ate two meals People of the Book How to drink Proper grooming How to put on and take off shoes How to urinate How to defecate Siwak

Political Ad Hadith Recommended to Kill Kharijites Kill believers who fight the Ummah Yazid bin Mu'awiyah destroys Ka'aba Succession People of the House Pro 'Aisha Pro Ali Pro-Uthman Pro Quraish Pro Umayyad Pro Ubayy bin Ka'b Pro Sa'd Pro Mas'ud Pro-Sunni (Companion Idolization)Pro Abu Sufyan Pro Yemen Pro Ansar Anti-Ali Anti-Fitna Anti Mu'awaiyah Anti-Bedouin Ijma Ulema Can't Do Wrong Pro Salaf Kill the supporters and the contender to the Caliph Blind obedience to Caliph Fight Jews Pro Sunnah and Caliph Anti-Quran Alone Muslims will ransom Jews and Christians for Hell Following Jews and Christians Do the opposite of Jews and Christians

Abu Hurairah Arrived after battle of Khaibar Spoke Perisan (Farsi)Jewish Influence Liar Beware of Man who Narrates Everything he Hears Abu Hurairah Narrates Too Much 'Aisha Denounce Abu Hurairah Narrations Abu Hurairah never forgets Insulting Hagar Ways to be martyred Talking Cow and Wolf Prophecy Faces of Prostitutes Abraham's circumcision A tribe of Jews became mice Adam and Moses debate Prophet's Sandal Moses Punches Angel of Death Donkey Transformation Bad Tafsir Zakariya was a carpenter Israiliyat

Satan and Jinns Satan's Antics Satan breaking wind Catching Satan Satan can't open doors Satan waits in our nose when we sleep Yawning Snakes and Jinns Jinns eat bones and dung Satan eats with the left hand Satan stealing food Black dogs are Shaitan Camels are from Satan Black goats are Satan Satan Can't Impersonate Prophet in Dreams Feeding Jinns Talking to Jinns

Bad Science Child Gender Adam's Height Child's Resemblance Black Cumin: The cure for every disease Only 3 forms of healing Tailbone preservation Camel urine Treat Wounds With Saliva Mountain Goats Above Heaven Ajwa Dates: Protection from poison and magic Disease Cheat Code God comes near Earth at night Fly in Drink Embryology The Earth, Fish, and Ox Human Height Salman al-Farsi Lived 250-350 years Cupping Cure Every Disease Bad Math Source of Thunder 500 Years Summer and Winter Weather Forecast Where the sun sets Prophet Ascribed to Fal (Fortune Telling)No Contagious Disease

Quraish Religion Believed in Abraham, Ishmael, and Mary 360 Idols at Kaaba Hajj Companions request idols Dedicated Meat Stone Worship False Prophet During Muhammad's Life People of Allah Written Injeel Quraish didn't think they were associating partners with God Quraish believed in messengers but rejected Muhammad Pre-Islamic Marriage Adhan Quraish had Li'an Kaaba Rebuilt

Quran Compilation Written Quran (Mus'haf)Four People Collected Quran Uthman's Mus'haf 9:128-129 Sura Bara'a Revealed at Once Consolidating Suras 8 & 9 33:23 Altered Verse Mus'haf in the dialect of Quraish Mus'haf in the dialect of Mudar Prophet was not illiterate Companions Misquote Quran Ahruf Ambiguity about verses Abrogated Suras Abrogated verses Lost Verses Stoning Verse Satanic Verses Ibn Mas'ud Quran

Additional Resources

حَدَّثَنَا إِسْمَاعِيلُ بْنُ أَبِي أُوَيْسٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ وَهْبٍ، عَنْ يُونُسَ، عَنِ ابْنِ شِهَابٍ، عَنْ عُرْوَةَ بْنِ الزُّبَيْرِ، وَعَمْرَةَ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ، عَنِ النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم قَالَ ‏ "‏ تُقْطَعُ يَدُ السَّارِقِ فِي رُبُعِ دِينَارٍ ‏"‏‏.‏

Narrated’Aisha: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "The hand of a thief should be cut off for stealing a quarter of a Dinar."

Sahih al-Bukhari 6790 https://sunnah.com/bukhari:6790

See also: https://sunnah.com/bukhari:6791

حَدَّثَنَا عُثْمَانُ بْنُ أَبِي شَيْبَةَ، حَدَّثَنَا عَبْدَةُ، عَنْ هِشَامٍ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ، قَالَ أَخْبَرَتْنِي عَائِشَةُ، أَنَّ يَدَ السَّارِقِ، لَمْ تُقْطَعْ عَلَى عَهْدِ النَّبِيِّ صلى الله عليه وسلم إِلاَّ فِي ثَمَنِ مِجَنٍّ حَجَفَةٍ أَوْ تُرْسٍ‏.‏ حَدَّثَنَا عُثْمَانُ، حَدَّثَنَا حُمَيْدُ بْنُ عَبْدِ الرَّحْمَنِ، حَدَّثَنَا هِشَامٌ، عَنْ أَبِيهِ، عَنْ عَائِشَةَ، مِثْلَهُ‏.‏

Narrated Aisha: The hand of a thief was not cut off during the lifetime of the Prophet (ﷺ) except for stealing something equal to a shield in value. A similar hadith is narrated from Aisha through another chain.

Note: a shield at the time was worth one dinar.

Sahih al-Bukhari 6792 https://sunnah.com/bukhari:6792

Kind	Document
Author	Quran Talk
Publisher	Quran Talk
Published	February 12, 2026
Collection	Research
Standing	Commentary or other writing

Address	https://www.wikisubmission.org/library/work/problematic-sahih-hadith-e04be361d25922d5
ID	01a18b39-06ba-77ff-95b1-e108ec3f99df

Languages

With each verse

Severing Hands

Contents